Dear Congressman Courtney,
My name is David Coffey. I’m a 23-year-old graduate of Eastern Connecticut State University. I graduated with my major in Political Science, and I support Bernie Sanders.
Let me first tell you that we have met before. You came to the second congressional district’s Bernie Sanders office in Norwich to listen to me and several other Bernie supporters. To my understanding, you were the only representative from the five districts in Connecticut who came to meet with us. For that, I thank you.
I would also like to thank you for the work you’ve done for Connecticut. You have consistently gotten the endorsement of the Working Families Party, and I have voted for you on more than one occasion. Thank you for being the best choice when I went to the polls.
On October 19th, 2015, you announced on your website that you, “heartily endorse Hillary Clinton as the Democratic Nominee to become the next president of the United States.” I respect your decision, and I respect that you’ve listened to the reasons why so many of your constituents disagree with you. That being said, there’s more that I’d like to express. I think it is especially important in the context of you being one of Connecticut’s superdelegates.
When you came to the Bernie headquarters in Norwich, you stuck around to talk to us one-on-one, which was excellent. I was even fortunate enough to speak with you. I told you about how for the past few years I’ve been a cynic about the American political system. I then went on to say that, “Bernie is threatening to kill my cynicism.”
You laughed. I kept a straight face.
I doubt you meant any malice in your response. And, admittedly, I probably could have phrased what I said better. But it was not meant to be a joke. My loss of faith in the Democratic Party, and politics in general, was a gradual one.
I remember being optimistic when I saw Obama get elected for the first time. I really thought my country, despite its hardships and shortcomings, was on a path to get better. I was a patriot and I proudly voted in my first state election in 2010.
Things changed when I went to college in 2011. This was right about the time that Occupy Wall Street came into being. It excited me to see so many people coming together to protest corporate greed— something that the Democratic Party claims to take a strong stand against. I even heard Obama say something to the effect of, “these people are the reason I ran for president.”
My optimism ended shortly thereafter. I watched protestors get beaten, maced, and have their right to freedom of expression trampled upon. Not only in Zuccotti Park, but at UC Davis, in the streets of Oakland, and several other occupations. I was afraid to express myself. This was not the kind of country I wanted to live in.
I can understand wanting to distance oneself from the Occupy movement. There were demonstrators with extreme views. But still, never once did I hear Obama speak out on the police brutality. With all due respect, I also do not recall you ever saying anything. Neither of you ever called out the brutality or commented on the protestors’ right to expression. (Correct me if I’m wrong. For the record, though, Sanders did speak in support of the demonstrations.) I did not see nearly as much force—if any—used against right-wing protests like the Tea Party.
Through all this, though, I still kept my head up. I still had faith in the Democratic Party and the Obama administration to represent the people in the end. That last bit of faith died when Obama got a super PAC in 2012.
Having previously condemned Super PACs, Obama had now embraced big money. I felt like I was not represented. This was a clear message that money really did rule politics-no matter which party. (The recent rolling back on lobbying restrictions by the DNC furthers this point.) For these reasons-and a variety of others I do not have the time to mention-I have been an unaffiliated voter ever since.
It was not until Bernie started running that I registered with the Democratic Party.
Bernie has consistently fought for noble causes. He was ahead of his time on matters such as gay rights, civil rights, income inequality and economic justice, and foreign policy. Bernie has stuck to his principles, even when they were not popular.
Sadly, Hillary Clinton simply doesn’t have the consistency in her record. She claims to have always championed gay rights, but during her time as a senator, she defined marriage as between a man and a woman. She claims to have always been for worker’s rights yet supported NAFTA. She claims to always have been supportive of minority rights yet campaigned for Barry Goldwater, an arch conservative who opposed the Civil Rights Act.
Just recently, Hillary was presented with an opportunity to prove what kind of politician she was. At a recent event she was hosting in South Carolina, she was interrupted by a Black Lives Matter protestor. The protester asked about Hillary’s part in the tougher crime laws that disproportionately put African-Americans in prison. She also asked about her comments about “at risk youth,” and her allegation that black youth were “Super Predators.”
Claiming that “no one had ever asked” her about that, she had the young woman removed. Bear in mind, this woman had paid $500 to be at this event in an attempt to reach out to someone running for the highest office in the country. Hillary barely acknowledged her and after she was removed, she said, “back to the issues,” as if racial justice and mass incarceration did not matter.
Now, contrast this against the way Bernie handled a similar situation in Seattle. Two Black Lives Matter protestors interrupted Bernie-and much more forcefully than the woman in South Carolina. Did Bernie have security escort the women off of the premises as Hillary did?
He did not.
Acknowledging that every American has a right to express themselves—even if it is critical of him—he let them speak. Bernie politely stood back, and let them express their contempt with the system. Agree with the protestors or not—every American deserves to be listened to. That is the very essence of democracy.
Tell me, which of these two candidates sounds like the candidate of the people?
I recall you saying that, as a superdelegate, you were going to vote with your conscience. That is how you voted in past elections. You brought up how in 2008 you went against the will of your district and voted for Obama-even though the 2nd Congressional District voters went for Hillary. I don’t fully understand what changed to make you endorse a politician that you opposed not so long ago.
How can your conscience side with a candidate who campaigned for segregation in the sixties over one who protested segregation during the same era? How can you, in good conscience, support a candidate who took millions in speaking fees from the same banks she claims to oppose?
Furthermore, in regards to these speaking fees: when Hillary was asked about releasing the transcripts of her speeches, she said that she would release them “when everyone else does.” She has let the Republicans, and other public officials that have been financed by wealthy individuals, set her personal standard on how to deal with campaign transparency.
The point I am getting at is that we have another option in Bernie Sanders. We have the option to vote for a candidate who defied the odds, and has successfully run a campaign without a Super PAC. We have a candidate who is not beholden to wealthy Wall Street executives. We have a candidate who is principled enough to always fight for the working and middle class. Listen to Bernie’s speeches; he has been committed to his principles for decades.
You say that you are, “particularly heartened by Hillary’s call for tackling student loan debt.” Meanwhile, Bernie has a precise plan to make student loan debt a non-issue. (Look into his .05% tax on Wall Street transactions.) He also wants to save social security by doing away with the cap on taxable income. Meanwhile, Hillary has failed to present a precise plan on this issue.
Please, Mr. Courtney, and this goes for all Democratic Party representatives, make the right choice. This goes beyond the presidency, this is about the future of the Democratic Party. This is about your children’s’ future, what kind of America do you want to leave for them?
Make no mistake; I do not think that Sanders can single-handedly save America. I am not naïve. I know that the Democratic Party is going to have work very hard and cooperatively to get things done. The effort can’t end after November 8th.
I do think electing Sanders, though, will be a great step in the right direction for the Democratic Party to win back its legitimacy. Sanders is truly a people’s candidate, and he is unifying people in a way that Hillary simply cannot. (I know multiple people who have changed their party affiliation from Republican to Democrat because of Sanders-none for Hillary.)
I want to see the Democratic Party listen to and represent all people, not just a wealthy, elite few. I don’t want my cynicism, and the cynicism of so many other millennials, to overpower my will to be politically active. Again, think of the future of your party, and more importantly, think of the future of the country that you’re leaving for your children.
For one of the first times in my life, my generation feels hope.
Regards,
David Taylor Coffey
